UPDATING THE BRAKING MECHANISMS IN NO-FAULT DIVORCE LAWS:
A PROPOSAL FOR AN EARLY WARNING/PREVENTION SYSTEM FOR DIVORCE
By John Crouch, JD, with Richard Beaulieu
Part of the Divorce
Reform Page, sponsored by Americans for Divorce
Reform
Legislation
| Statistics | Articles/Opinion
| Quotations | Polls
| Other family-related
articles
The Abstract of the Study
Contents:
No-fault divorce - the original vision
No-fault divorce now
What the Counseling Periods Act does
Exceptions
Marriage education, counseling in the Act
Mutual Consent
Core text of Counseling Periods Act
Appendices:
A sample Early Warning and Prevention Notice.
Introduction to the Marriage and Divorce Counseling
Pd Act
The Full Text of The Marriage and Divorce Counseling
Period Act
No-fault divorce - the original vision:
- Based on successful Los Angeles "Conciliation Court" - a marriage
hospital where most marriages healed, others euthanized
- Mutual consent of both spouses was important factor or requirement
- Waiting periods
- Court-directed reconciliation counseling
- Judge must verify genuine "irretrievable breakdown" of marriage
No-fault divorce now:
- "Irretrievable breakdown" became "if one spouse wants
divorce"
- Waiting periods, consent requirements survive only where state laws
expressly demand them
- Court reconciliation counseling faded away, was too little, too late
- One spouse "tries everything" and gives up on marriage before
the other spouse recognizes a problem
- Once one spouse decides to divorce, usually too late to save marriage
- Unilateral divorce laws increase mutual distrust during separation,
make reconciliation harder
- Some waiting periods require strict separation - this discourages reconciliation
- Fault or contested divorces still take years
- Waiting periods, counseling laws need to be redesigned to adapt to modern
life and unilateral divorce environment
What the Counseling Periods Act does:
- Gives couples a common language to communicate early warning signals
- Helps them repair marriages before it's too late
- Wait period varies from 6 months to 2 years, depending on children and
mutual consent
- Based on existing laws in Maryland, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New Jersey
& Puerto Rico
- But with new twist - puts waiting period BEFORE decision to divorce
- Wait starts with notice/request for help, NOT by leaving or filing for
divorce
- Does not encourage "fault" divorce - applies equally to fault
and no-fault
- Replaces archaic "cruelty" laws, procedures; piggybacks on
existing system for domestic violence restraining orders
Exceptions: Counseling Period NOT required
after:
- Conviction of violent crime in family
- Restraining order for family violence
- Imprisonment or institutionalization (if those are divorce grounds in
the state)
Marriage education, counseling in the Act:
- Not mandatory
- Maximizes opportunities, time, information, incentives for marriage
education
- All family courts, family service agencies, marriage license offices
provide information on marriage education
- Careful, flexible definition of marriage education / educators
Mutual Consent in the Act:
- Not mandatory, but a major incentive
- Consent must be specific agreement on all issues - not just superficial
agreement
Core text of Counseling Periods Act
I. CONSIDERATION AND COUNSELING PERIOD BEFORE DIVORCE
A. No one may ask a court for a divorce until after a Counseling
and Consideration Period
B. The Counseling and Consideration Period is two years, minus six months
for each of the following circumstances:
- The parties have never had children
- The parties have a written agreement on the divorce and all issues
- After the Period begins, the parties get marriage education
C. The Counseling and Consideration Period begins when one spouse delivers
a Marriage Help Request Notice to the other spouse.
Legislation
| Statistics | Articles/Opinion
| Quotations | Polls
| Other family-related
articles
Originally posted and maintained by Americans
for Divorce Reform; now maintained by John Crouch. You can call me at
(703) 528-6700 or e-mail
me through my law office's web site.